Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Statehouse Clown Show

I've been avoiding comment on the California budget situation, which has gone from bad to ridiculous. But my native state is an object lesson in our topic of the last few days - well of this whole blog, really: replace social with market economics, watch everything fall apart. It's an object lesson in this blog's other topic: the failure of the political class worldwide.

The LA Times story today is "Legislature adjourns with no budget; governor prepares to lay off 10,000." The large Dim majority needs more or less one Republican to vote with them to beat the 2/3 limit for tax increases. The Republicans, unable to face the reality that on economics they are ALWAYS WRONG, have taken a no-tax pledge. The result will be the shutdown of every single public project in the state, and mass layoffs to add to the furlong.

Schwarzenegger now gets to star as Herbert Hoover in his own movie called "I, Arnold - Depression Governor." He was cast in the role by his own party, whose rank-and-file is also ignoring their own party leadership.

Here's the circle of geniuses that are holding 40 million people hostage with their ideological narcissism and general lack of a grip on reality.

That's GOP Sens. George Runner, Sam Aanestad, John Benoit and Bob Dutton, from left, and Dave Cox, seated.

Genius, you ask. Is my sarcasm a little harsh? Well here's swing vote holdout Abel Maldonado (R-Central Coast) in his own genius words:
Last week, I sent a letter to the Big 5 demanding that the funding be removed from the budget and allocated to other programs. But instead, the Big 5 ignored my request. If they were truly making a good-faith effort to show the people of California that they were serious about fixing this budget problem, the million dollars would have been re-appropriated to a vital program.
Etc. Seems that Genius Maldonado, self-described son of farmworkers, ran for the Republican nomination for Controller, was shut out by his own party for voting for a budget compromise in 2006, and is mad that the current Controller has $1 million for "office furniture," or whatever. Ergo, no state budget. Ergo, tens of thousands are out of work.

Maldonado to current farm workers (and every other kind): let them eat office furniture! Pure genius!

Sunday, February 15, 2009

Everything You Need to Know in 3 min 50

The best three sentence description of the global crisis is in U Mass economist Rick Wolff's movie, Capitalism Hits the Fan. Actually its one of the best explanations of any length, complete with nice charts like this one. Don't miss it - so much better than the usual Sunday thumbsuckers.

My capitalist pals are hearing the whirring blades as well.

Saturday, February 14, 2009

Nationalizers Inside the House

One of my favorite horror movies is When A Stranger Calls. The line that made my stand up and shriek in a New Jersey theater full of strangers in 1980 comes when a cop calls back the babysitter who's been getting crank calls ("have you checked the children?"). He tells her, "we've traced the call. It's coming from inside the house." Shrieeeek.

Progressive and left economists have been doing this. It's worth reading the whole transcript of Michael Hudson and Robert Kuttner on Democracy Now yesterday. Here's Kuttner:
if you look at Citigroup, the Treasury has put in $45 billion of direct equity capital into Citigroup. It’s guaranteed another $306 billion of toxic assets. You can buy all of Citigroup for about $25 billion. So the taxpayers effectively own it. What the government ought to do is exercise the rights of ownership, go in there, put a majority of public appointees on the board, get rid of existing management. I think in the case of Citigroup, the best thing you could do is break it up, because it is a zombie bank in the sense of it being insolvent. And most of the large banks are insolvent. Their debts exceed their capital. And what Geithner is doing, he’s trying to just disguise this by one more effort to double down using the same kind of financial razzle dazzle that got us into this trouble. So it would be much cleaner to put these banks into receivership.

And if that sounds radical, it is radical, but it’s important to keep in mind that the FDIC, which is the one agency that’s behaved responsibly in this whole mess, the FDIC does this every day of the week.
But here's self-described "free market economists" Matthew Richardson and Nouriel Roubini of NYU's Stern school saying "We're All Swedes Now." Why? Because they have traced the call and it's coming from inside the house:
The subprime mortgage mess alone does not force our hand; the $1.2 trillion it involves is just the beginning of the problem. Another $7 trillion -- including commercial real estate loans, consumer credit-card debt and high-yield bonds and leveraged loans -- is at risk of losing much of its value. Then there are trillions more in high-grade corporate bonds and loans and jumbo prime mortgages, whose worth will also drop precipitously as the recession deepens and more firms and households default on their loans and mortgages.
In other words, they are scared out of their minds.

Same goes for the experienced but polite-society NYT business journalist Joe Nocera, who finds members of his corporate "kitchen cabinet" saying "Nationalize It!" The process all begin with a real stress test, which I prefer to call the Banking Inquisition.

It's interesting to watch a certain kind of capitalist rationality pushing on its long-time advocates. The first element is correct accounting, the second is actual market value, and the third is rights of ownership. The first shows up when a former IMF official tells Nocera that governments must take over insolvent banks: "This is exactly what the I.M.F. tells an emerging market country to do when it is facing a crisis — like Thailand in 1997, or Russia in 1998."

The third shows up in Nocera's final salvo:
Whatever solution winds up working, it is going to cost the taxpayers billions. That’s a given. The S.& L. crisis — which was a piffle compared to what we face now — cost well over $100 billion by the time it was over. In return, shouldn’t the taxpayer be the one to hold the majority ownership stake in the banks? And shouldn’t the government have the right to decide that perhaps Ken Lewis should no longer be running Bank of America? And isn’t the best way to protect taxpayers — the mantra we heard all week long — to take control of what they are financing? It can be done right. It has been before.
We're seeing a convergence of left solutions to the crisis and moderate insider solutions. This is the inside call that is frightening Republicans.

But only the left will follow through with what we really need: a democratized banking system that is much cheaper for the overall economy than the current one. Democratization requires a distribution of knowledge about the financial system that is beyond anything seen so far in modern history.

The reorganized "sustainable economy" party will need the political organization to fend off attacks, but also a vast intellectual base. In addition to the folks mentioned above, there is William Greider on the ongoing banker squeeze on Social Security, and Dean Baker's weekly critiques of the Washington Post's relentless campaign against the big "entitlements." There are excellent longer analyzes like Peter Gowan's in the New Left Review.

Can we have some Principles from all this?
  • a end to the financial double standard: a bank may be borrowing at 4% and charging you 21% on your credit card. This has to stop. End it through
  • anti-usury laws. these are a subset of
  • regulatory equity. Investment firms need to be part of general legal frameworks just like everybody else. And this would lead to:
  • tax equity. Financial transactions are largely untaxed. The "Tobin Tax" of even 0.25% on currency trading was one example, has been completely blocked by the financial industry.
For any of this to happen, we need massively more consistent popular attention to the financial details coming from the 80-90% of the population that will otherwise be paying the bill. That's where the next call needs to come from.

Friday, February 13, 2009

Good Cop Bad Cop

You know something is happening when an NYU economist writes a credit report that says, "The United States banking system is effectively insolvent."

If you add up the numbers in Krugman's good column today you get this:

Bush's tax cuts: $2 trillion
Bush's Iraq war: $1 trillion (Joseph Stiglitz's estimate is closer to $3 trillion, most still ahead)
Bank bailout: $2 trillion (dismal but plausible estimate)

plus
Lost GDP 08-11:$4 trillion

That's $9 trillion down (on a 14.5 trillion annual gross domestic product). This is a crude way of explaining why many economists think a stimulus of 1/10th of "lost" public revenues is too small.

Then we have the shrunken stimulus plan. What does it mean?

Here is Scenario 1: Obama is Good Cop. Republicans are Bad Cop. Obama wanted more for the people. He mostly won, but had to give up a few suckers to Bad Cop.

No one is better on Scenario 1 than Krugman. He couldn't help mention the utterly unrepentant Republicans: "In both the House and the Senate, the vast majority of Republicans rallied behind the idea that the appropriate response to the abject failure of the Bush administration’s tax cuts is more Bush-style tax cuts."

Krugman traced this boneheaded intransigence to the GOP's enforcers, ready to shoot their heretics. These are the same folks that would rather the party lose with a hardcore right-winger like Sarah Palin than lose the party to a moderate who could have won. The zero Republican votes for the stimulus in the House was in part a sign of the ongoing frantic activism of the party's right wing, which is still in charge. These are the people whose power both ideologically and economically has rested on anti-egalitarian Reaganomics, so they will die hard.

But there's Scenario 2. The Republicans are Bad Cop. Obama is Bad Cop. There is no Good Cop.

This scenario takes off from the observation that Obama was Wall Street's candidate. Politico's summary is that "The list of top donors to the trio’s campaigns includes many firms at the heart of the financial meltdown — including taxpayer-funded bailout beneficiaries Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America — and a host of other troubled investment houses that may find themselves seeking money from the new Obama administration, which has also pledged tougher regulations." There's also this nice list of "Obama's Sub-Prime Buddies."

The scenario continues with the failure to refund failed mortgages directly, the woeful shortfall of money to the states (Bob Kuttner says they got $140 billion of the $500 billion of estimated need -the "Stabilization Fund" for states is $54 billion). It winds through the odd vagueness of Treasury's new bank plan (when bankers start pondering history, we are screwed). It continues with the reporters at the NYT politely hinting that the needs of the banks may have no end. It gets truly noir with Michael Hudson's argument that the government will have taken $12 trillion of public money and given it to banks. As he puts it, "the debt is going to continue to grow exponentially, and it’s way beyond the ability of the economy to pay. If people have to pay the amount of debt that they have now, there won’t be any money to buy goods and services, companies will not sell as much, they’ll invest less, they’ll hire less, and they’ll continue to downsize." The scenario culminates with Hudson's claim that the bad debts are concentrated in a handful of gigantic banks, who are using the bailout money to buy and thereby "infec[t] the small healthy banks."

What if we are saving the banks by killing the economy?

It's zombie perfection. What if the whole plan is to take general wealth and move even more of it up to the very top of the financial pyramid? What better way than to have cut bank and corporate tax rates for decades, let them sell houses to people via unafforable mortgages that allow them to take the houses back, turn mortgages into toxic securities that blow the legs off pension funds, and then go so bust that they need all of the country's money for their bailout. The banks get the houses, the mortgages, the securities, and the tax dollars, which they use to launder the securities and sell them back later to the crippled pension funds.

What if Obama is Reagan come back to life?

Now that's noir.

After all this, there's always a little comic relief. David "Schoolboy" Brooks has always been silly, but now he literally makes no sense. He throws some numbers out, quotes Tocqueville, mentions cognitive scientists and says we've lost our high-trust society, has no ending at all, and writes as though he were living in 2017. If W was our worse president, Schoolboy is our dumbest scholar. He should be on the list of People that Won't Be Having Sex in 2009.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

House-Senate: Zero-Zero

The middle-class won in the House-Senate conference on the stimulus by keeping the suspension of the Alternative Minimum Tax that had been hitting it - its upper reaches for years. It lost by seeing huge cuts in education, construction, and health care.

Medical research won because Arlen Specter the cancer survivor was a key Republican vote. In fact, the NYT reporters imply the whole thing was decided by the three "centrist" Republicans and their personal opinions. "it was clear that the three Republicans who agreed to support the bill in the Senate wielded extraordinary power, and along with conservative Democrats in their coalition, had put a firm stamp on the stimulus package."

It's a great way to run a country with 300 million people.

The whole package is 1/3 the size of the bailout for the banks.

The proportion between the deal for finance and the deal for the other 300,000,000 is the exact continuation of Reaganism through its Bushian decadence: public resources must go to the top. The true sign of efficiency is gross inequality.

The British political scientist Ross McKibbin summed up the Reagan-Thatcher model in the London Review of Books:
What is the function of the Conservative Party? It is to defend inequality: to make acceptable the social and economic unfairness inherent in a predominantly capitalist economy; to preserve the interests and privileges of social elites. But historically it has not been committed to a particular strategy to fulfil these aims.
In other words, because of its powerful electoral and financial advantages for the Republicans, inequality must continue by any means necessary. That is the underlying message of the House-Senate vote.

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Why There is No Bottom

It's because there is no financial truth. James Galbraith said it very well today:
Well, the crucial question is, on what terms does the Treasury plan to guarantee or to repurchase or to otherwise deal with the bad assets that the banks have? These assets are mortgage-backed securities. They are securities derived from subprime loans that were made in an atmosphere of regulatory laxness and complicity and fraud, basically, during the Bush administration, which came to take over the system of housing finance and to infect it with assets which nobody trusts, which nobody can value. And nobody really knows what’s in the files, what’s on the loan tapes of those—that underlie those securities. So the question that I think we need to ask is, before we issue a public guarantee, does the Treasury of the United States plan to conduct a meticulous audit of the assets that underlie the securities that they’re expecting to take off the banks’ books, so that we, the taxpayer, can have an idea of what, if anything, these securities are worth?
And the problem is that when you—the little bit of checking that has been done appears to reveal that a very large fraction of these securities contain, on the face of it, misrepresentation or fraud in the files. And so, we are looking at an asset which nobody, no outside investor doing due diligence on behalf of a client for whom they have some responsibility, would touch. And that is the issue. That’s the problem.

If that is indeed the case, then I think it’s fair to conclude that the large banks, which the Treasury is trying very hard to protect, cannot in fact be protected, that they are in fact insolvent, and that the proper approach for dealing with them is for the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation to move in and take the steps that the FDIC normally takes when dealing with insolvent banks.
Business Week is on the same beat. So is the NYT, with a very good piece about Geithner who seems to be Trojan horsing for the big dying banks. "But as intended largely by Mr. Geithner, the plan stops short of intruding too significantly into bankers’ affairs even as they come onto the public dole."

Geithner belly-flopped today. Out of the sky, straight into the seal

Monday, February 09, 2009

You Try to Live on 500K in This Town

haw - pretty damn funny.

Why We Need the Corporate Inquisition

The 9/11 attacks got an investigation, as did various major assassinations, so why not investigate a global crash with deep roots in deliberate, systematic financial engineering built with American financial theory? The theory was built on a right-wing version of neoclassical economics - private decisions always good, public decisions always bad, inequality of wealth and income always good (expressing a natural order), equality always bad (restricting liberty and entrepreneurship). It failed in practice, so let's sort and analyze the wreckage like we do with plane crashes that kill many fewer people than this crash is killing.

Paul Krugman today combines critique of the compromise Senate bailout with an accurate attack on bipartisanship. The key passage:
Mr. Obama’s postpartisan yearnings may also explain why he didn’t do something crucially important: speak forcefully about how government spending can help support the economy. Instead, he let conservatives define the debate, waiting until late last week before finally saying what needed to be said — that increasing spending is the whole point of the plan.

And Mr. Obama got nothing in return for his bipartisan outreach. Not one Republican voted for the House version of the stimulus plan, which was, by the way, better focused than the original administration proposal.
I'm having Clinton flashbacks.

The basics behind Krugman's assessment can be found in a Financial Times summary (my archive version). By their count, 40% of the Senate stimulus is tax cuts.

The God That Failed will keep issuing orders unless He is taken out by the Inquisition. The paradigm has to change, and change very quickly.

Sunday, February 08, 2009

Sunday Talking in France

On France 5's Sunday show "Riposte," Maryse Dumas, one of the leaders of the major union CGT pointed out that over the past 10 years, dividends to shareholders in French public companies have grown 7 times faster than salaries. She asked why the representative of a business organization, Jerome Bedier, had just said France's problem vis-a-vis Germany was that employees just cost too much in France.

Well, because it's a traditional corporate smokescreen that distracts folks from the reality of decades of flat or falling wages for 80% of the population. Black is white, day is night, the sun rises in the west. And "we need to revalorize work" because the financial crisis came about when teachers and train conductors decided they didn't value work anymore.

If the French didn't have 4 weeks of vacation none of this crisis shit would have happened. Now give me a PhD in Econ.

The fired head of Merrill Lynch will work, as long as you give him a $40 million bonus afterwards. In the case of his demand of 0.4 of a Texas Unit for selling Merrill to Bank of America, he wanted it for dumping the company that he had helped sink as its CEO.

The article on the subject, by Louise Story and Julie Crewell, is a really nice piece of reporting on the delusional world of Wall Street America, a parallel universe in which chief executives become Sun Kings by acting like this:
[Thain] surrounded himself with former colleagues. In addition to luring his N.Y.S.E. deputies, he showered cash on former Goldman executives to bring them to Merrill. He paid $25 million to Peter S. Kraus, who ran Goldman’s investment management unit, to oversee business strategy at Merrill. He shelled out $39 million to Thomas K. Montag, who was co-head of Goldman’s global securities unit, to run Merrill’s trading operations.
What can anyone say? These executives will enter history along with Gen. Custer and Charles Ponzi, and other epic blowhards who took down legions of people with them. Back on Riposte, Maurice Szafran, from the relentlessly critical weekly Marianne, asked when Nicholas le Jogger Sarkoky would admit that his own policies had helped contribute to the crisis. Answer, in America, is never. Fr Frank preaches it right again this morning, noting the stacking of the Obama deck with foxes who ate the hens and then charged us $750 billion to scare up some new ones.

And on Riposte, Valerie Pecresse, Sarko le J's minister of higher education whose "reform" of universities has lead to nationwide university strikes, said things will be much better if university presidents have the power to "manage" the careers of the professors on their staffs.

Don't close Gitmo. As long as America still tortures a little bit, lets use Gitmo for the Corporate Inquisition.

Saturday, February 07, 2009

Why are They in Charge??? A Real Question

I analyze "Senate to Universities: Drop Dead" on a related blog. But on the question of infrastructure, the investment guys at Money Morning stop whaling on dumb and crooked bank execs long enough to raise the question of $35 trillion in infrastructure needs coming up in the next twenty years. See the links in "drop dead" for the opposite work being done in our alleged knowledge economy. CBIC World Markets, who wrote the report, thinks correctly that part of the problem is fake budget balancing that led to skimping on existing needs. Nice backlog for the kids and greatgrandkids to work on, if they aren't sweating too much in the new lizard-skins that protect them from the warmed-up planet.

The Business Genius of the Week story award goes to an NYT piece about Sam Zell. Actually Sam Zell looks like he dumped all 573 of his business properties just in time. But the buyers - classic suckers with very big paychecks and the very best credentials. Crucial moments:
  • the middleman who bought the buildings from Zell and then flipped most of them to the suckers was hedge fund Blackstone and its King Genius Steven Schwarzman (who still has his money btw).
  • "Buyers purchased buildings at what, in retrospect, were vastly inflated prices."
  • "Lenders provided lavish, even excessive, financing based on unrealistic expectations of rising rents."
  • "And now that values are tumbling, vacancy rates are rising and credit has become impossibly tight, many on both sides are struggling against default, foreclosure or bankruptcy."
The last three are all one paragraph. But they get at the essential mechanics. These guys were being paid astronomically to not be as stupid as this.

But the gods were stupid:
  • "The list of Equity Office buyers reads like a Who’s Who in American real estate. In Stamford, Conn., RFR Properties, a partnership headed by Michael Fuchs and Aby Rosen, who owns Manhattan landmarks like Lever House and the Seagram Building, spent $850 million to buy seven Equity Office buildings that analysts say are now worth less than their mortgages."
Turns out it didn't matter whether they were stupid or not. They got paid either way.

  • "The buyers found lenders only too willing to finance as much as 90 percent or more of the purchase price, even as profit margins shrank, on a bet that rents and values would continue to rise. The investment banks, including Morgan Stanley, Wachovia, Goldman Sachs, Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers, in turn collected their fees as they packaged the loans as securities and sold them to investors."
Remember that the next time you get a lecture from a trader about how big risk-taking deserves the big bucks.

Plus, they were collecting big fees by not using any of their own money.

  • "In New York, Mr. Macklowe made a characteristically aggressive gamble when he bought seven Midtown buildings from Blackstone for more than $6 billion, doubling the size of his real estate empire. He put down a mere $50 million, while lining up $7 billion in short-term financing from Deutsche Bank and the Fortress Investment Group for the acquisition."

And then, enter the rest of us:
  • "If the owners cannot make their loan payments, it could create a financial crisis for the pension funds, hedge funds and insurance companies that hold securities based on Equity Office mortgages."
  • "In Austin, when the Thomas Properties Group formed a partnership with the California teachers’ pension fund and Lehman Brothers, which was also a lender in the deal, to buy 10 Equity Office buildings downtown and in the surrounding suburbs for $1.15 billion, it instantly became the biggest commercial landlord in town. Like many of the other deals, it was highly leveraged and dependent on rising rents. The problem is that rents are now declining in Austin, particularly in suburban areas, where vacancy rates have climbed to 14.4 percent as several new buildings are coming on line without tenants."

Monday, February 02, 2009

Power Struggles

By the way, the "unaffordable" $800 billion stimulus package? It's almost exactly the same as one year of the US military budget. And the stimulus won't all be spent in one year. So no big deal. We need it and we need it now. And then we're going to need another one later this year. That's OK - we can always break the DOD piggybank and get the whole sum right there!

The limits of Obaman economics is perfectly anatomized by Krugman today. "Bailouts for Bunglers?" Yes. Because even in the new administration private-sector executives must be in charge of the economy - no matter how terrible they are, how completely their ideas have failed, or how many GDPs of whole countries they manage to lose.
Meanwhile, a Washington Post report based on administration sources says that Mr. Geithner and Lawrence Summers, President Obama’s top economic adviser, “think governments make poor bank managers” — as opposed, presumably, to the private-sector geniuses who managed to lose more than a trillion dollars in the space of a few years.
The job cut bloodbath continues - 7000 down at Macy's. One story begins, "Macy’s Inc. plans to cut 7,000 jobs in a corporatewide restructuring that will centralize its operations and reduce expenses in one of the most difficult economic environments the retailer has faced." What is equally true is that they and thousands of other companies are creating the environment to which they "react." Every section of crew tossed over the side makes the ship sink that much more.

Same for Disney's announcement that it would lay off 5% of its workforce. ""Change is never easy and becomes even harder to embrace during times of turbulence and uncertainty," Anne Sweeney, president of the Disney/ABC Television Group, said in an e-mail to staff members." This is completely wrong. Bad change is never easy. Good change is a lot of fun. Firing, dissolution, forced resuffling, and a speed-up - why should anybody like that?

One classical issue here involves the mythical invisible hand. Since it does not exist, itcannot magically coordinate millions of private agents trying to save their skins with the traditional self-interested management reflex of firing 5-10% of the staff. The government tries to stimulate spending. Each business tries to decrease its spending. The government needs to win this battle, and needs to take power away from the private sector in order to do it.

Sunday, February 01, 2009

Give it Back!

Two of the major themes of the week are the continuation of mass layoffs as business's main stabilization strategy, and intellectual disarray in the economic and political leadership. Fr. Frank hits both notes today.

"What are Americans still buying," he asks. "Big Macs, Campbell’s soup, Hershey’s chocolate and Spam — the four food groups of the apocalypse."

Fr Frank does some nice bashing of Republican infantility, but we didn't expect them to be the source of ideas. The mass layoffs are more important, both for what they are doing to people's careeers and lives and for the unmet intellectual challenge they pose. In the decades that they were raising their salaries, as a multiple of the average line-worker's wage in their company, by more than a factor of ten, they came to define mass layoffs as part of the nature of things - and as their most brillant strategy for profit and share-price increases. This strategy damages individuals and society. It does nothing for economic development. Mass layoffs have to be criticized in they way that have been in places like France,

There is some emotional progress at least. Maureen Dowd outdoes herself in the NYT today - and not only because she chews the ass off the geniuses who sank the global economy but will pay themselves $18 billion in bonuses for 2008.

This in itself isn't actually news: Forbes guessed back in October that that the 2008 bonus pool would be between $19.9 and 23 billion, so the Masters of Disaster are a couple of billion below what they'd expected in the midst of the October crash.

Also last fall, Time estimated "rank-and-file investment banker" bonuses to average $625,000 for 2008, a bit more than half what they got the year before. This is a fraction of the rate for the top people - investment banking is the same feudal hierarchy of great-lord incomes as in the rest of the economy, only more so.

More to the point, the Masters have run the US economy with almost zero official criticism since, well, the death of Franklin Delano Roosevelt in 1945. The Depression was the last time the Captains of Industry sustained major damage from insiders.

Criticism of the way executives run the US economy has thus always had to come from outsiders. Ralph Nader's classic Unsafe at Any Speed (1965), revealed deliberate gross negligence of safety for the sake of maximized profits at General Motors set the tone for the 1960s - yes, they've been blowing off the constructive criticism that would have actually helped their company for 50 years. But it did not lead to a career as a legislator or respected expert who was regularly consulted in Washington, but to a career as an irritant and gadfly, influencing liberals and progressives from great distance from direct power or even expert commissions. The same has been true of civil rights leaders with critiques of the economy starting with Martin Luther King, whose Washington star was tarnished by the Poor People's March.

Washington has never listened to critics of capitalism or even to critics of the capitalists we actually suffer at any given time. Dowd is also pissed at official Washington. She wasn't impressed by Obama's comment that paying bonuses with taxpayer's money was the "height of irresponsibility," and cites Barney Frank, Congressional leader of the charge against the Bush solutions last fall, mumbling things like "“We got some preferred shares but I don’t think we could sue on that basis.”

The real question is why? Why is it that "Some Obama policy makers still buy into the notion that if they’re too strict, these economic royalists, to use F.D.R.’s epithet, might balk at the bailout, preferring perks over the prospect of their banks going belly-up"? Why do the Obamans care? If the banks go down so their execs can collect, the lawsuits will come from the shareholders. Meanwhile, economic royalism, which says that the people at the top should make all the important economic policy decisions by themselves, would be even more disgraced than it already is.

Obaman caution can only be explained by their desire to preserve the current system - royalist though it is. Obama's key financial advisors - Treasury Secretary, etc. - come from that system, e.g. the New York Fed - and were hired because of their record of seeking to fix and protect it. In his remarks Obama said that the government needs to "regulate Wall Street" so it starts doing things like lending money again. But if you need to regulate a system not just to keep it on the rails, but to force it to do its basic job, why are you hanging on to that system?

In contrast, Obama's actual and perhaps partially extemporized remarks were quite strong. The bonuses are the "height of irresponsibility. It is shameful." When he called on Wall Street to "show some restraint and show some discipline and show some sense of responsibility" he was accusing them of disloyalty to the overall economy. When he said that "taxpayers find themselves in the difficult position, that if they don't provide help, the system could come down on top of our heads," he was accusing them of extortion. When he repeatedly described Wall Street as consisting of people asking for help from the taxpayer, he reminded everyone of their combined weakness and hypocrisy. When he said the American people "don't like the idea that people are digging a bigger hole when they [the American people] are being asked to fill it up," he defined Wall Street's interests in direct opposition to the public's. When he pointed out that Treasury Secretay Geithner had had to "hold back" one firm that just received TARP money from buying a new jet, he implied an irresponsible selfishness was ingrained in Wall Street culture. "We shouldn't have to do that," he noted, "cause they should know better." But they didn't - and don't. He said that the American people are serious about moving forward. "I am serious," he added But Wall Street is the weakest link that is still feeding itself at the buffet table while the Titantic goes down.

Specialists know what occasionally leaks out to the press: investors often run strategies that help them while systematically damaging the economy. Reuters turned up one recently: a UK hedge fund earned nearly $400 million by massively shorting the stock of the Royal Bank of Scotland, which has been the recipient of 20 billion pounds in UK bailout money, and is now likely to be nationalized. (Enjoy the conservative Daily Telegraph likening the fired acquisitions maven, RBS's CEO Sir Fred "Fred the Shred" Goodwin to an "amateur property speculator," and calling him "a cipher for Brown's Britain – borrowing his and the bank's way to glory and riches.")

Another Principle for our list: Finance is as likely to undermine the real economy as to support it.

Is Obama's "new regulatory framework" really enough? A year ago I fantasized about "a day without a banker." The fantasy was prompted by research by Doug Henwood and others that suggests that the financial sector does not raise money for manufacturers and other operating companies, but extracts capital from them. If Wall Street in essence extracts a capital tax on the real economy, and uses it to pay its rank-and-file millions a year, and its executives tens or hundreds of millions, we can't afford it. We should get rid of it.

Dowd goes part of the way in translating "disgorgement." "Disgorgement," she writes, "is when courts force wrongdoers to repay ill-gotten gains. And I’m ill at the gains gotten by scummy executives acting all Gordon Gekko while they’re getting bailed out by us."

Amen, Ms Maureen! But we also need a Congressional investigation, Watergate-style, to find out who got what, how they got it, and whether cutting the Wall Street financing system is the tax cut the American people really need.

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Fiddle While Burning

There was good news in the failure of a SINGLE REPUBLICAN to support the new president's stimulus package, which won in the House 244-188 (11 Dims also voted against it): Obama learns early that compromising with the Republicans is a waste of time. Congressional Repubs are going to go down for the ideas that brought us the crisis in the first place. They will try to take us down with them.

The core Republican idea is that tax cuts are good and government spending is bad. There are two grounds for them saying this. One is "it's your money": is, you earned your salary yourself, supposedly without any help from government or society, so any taxation is either theft or charity. The premise is absurd, since every salary and fortune depends on a whole range of infrastructures, services, and work from other people. Still, it's a philosophical anchor for one of our somewhat backward country's two major parties.

The second ground is that private spending through tax cuts is more efficient than public spending. Various academic studies suggest that this is technically false: higher returns to the economy come from infrastructural investment than from tax cuts that are either saved or spent on consumer items, most of which are made outside the US and will thus export the stimulus. The record of private business is no better, as the bank record with their new government $350 billion shows: they didn't increase leading, but hoarded, merged, bought bonds, all of which were in their self-interest as they define it and not in that of the economy's.

The core fact that thirty years of Reaganism has tried to erase is that firms invest for themselves and not for society. They are legally and financially required to do this. Reaganism asserts that an invisible hand takes investment for one's firm (e.g. in telephone call centers in India or shoe factories in Malaysia) and translates it into maximum wealth for society. There was never any evidence for this, Adam Smith the supposed author didn't say it, and it has now in the real world come completely unglued.

Dims need to be militant on the higher values created by social investment or the Republicans will sink us all as surely as their forefathers did in 1930 and 1931.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Bore Me with Some Accounting

It is amazing to see Obama actually being president. It is amazing to have a black President of The United States. I still get a huge kick out of thinking that sentence.

Plus this week he did all sorts of direct and immediate things, including his orders ending at least some kinds of torture and ending the "global gag rule" on abortions.

One order Obama hasn't signed yet is the one that makes the bank bailout transparent. We're still where we were in November. No accounting, reckoning, explaining, or minimal tracing of the TARP funds expenditures.

There's also no repentance, conversion, rethinking - except for the moment of weakness from Greenspan. No one is sorry. The people who lost a ton of money got a whole lot more. Their Republican advocates are out there whaling away on the Obama plan as though their ideas and policies hadn't created the biggest financial disaster since, well, the last time they screwed up and created the Great Depression.

What will make them stop? What will get a plan in place that will help the non-rich? We need Watergate hearings or worse on why the system went so bad, where the money went, and how to get the money back into public systems.

Monday, January 19, 2009

Martin Now

It's hard to believe listening to him again on the radio how precise Martin Luther King was about the problems of his day - and, sad to say, our day as well.

Problems like: "war preventing programs" - programs for every kind of social progress. At one point he quoted a US Senator's estimate that the US was spending $500,000 to kill every Vietnamese solider, but only $53 per person to end poverty in the US.

The US story then, and the US story now, is the centrality of war, the weight of war spending, and more generally the irrationally of misspending in grotesque overproportion to suppress threats when their root causes should be fixed instead.

In the 1980s and 1990s it was "wealth preventing programs" - the piling up of huge fortunes in tech and finance that avoided the root causes once again.

What is it about us that makes us unable to stop?

King was great about the psychological underpinnings of the compulsive American errors - the helpless, defiant, and yet shame-filled, and reality-denying thread of uncontrollable feeling that backed it all. He once summarized the foundations of US foreign policy, with its world-alienating use of force to back oppressors, as "this melancholy body of obsessions."

Washington won't ever stop its backward choices unless the US population makes them stop.

Thank you for the reminders, MLK. And Happy Birthday.

Sunday, January 11, 2009

I'm Talking the Spanish Inquisition

Fr. Frank leads nicely today with the failure of account- ability, the failure of outrage for widespread federal mismanagement, and the absence of signs that the Bush nexus will be brought to justice. Since regular folks have only the law - no power, that is - this suggests that Obaman government will not be more responsive to the majority.

We need more than a figurehead. We need the bourgeois virtues of accounting and accountability.

We need a process, and mass support for investigation, explication, storytelling, and convicting - the great procedures of democratic process and crime fiction alike. As people like Joseph Stiglitz add up the Bush bill, the numbers are big enough to crush all recovery activities - if payback and just sourcing of funds doesn't start happening fast. We need inquests and investigations. We need the Spanish Inquisition.

One of Fr. Frank's links pointed me belatedly to the work of Eric Janszen, who has a good piece in this month's Harpers on the "next bubble," which includes a lot about our recent bubbles. Even more importantly, Janszen was as ahead of the curve on toxic assets and hedge-fund problems as Dean Baker was about the housing bubble. See his "Myth of the Slow Crash" from June 2006, which has some tasty charts about the Great Depression. It's true that the professional discussions are not as far behind as the public debate - see then Fed governor Ben Bernanke - now Federal Reserve chair - talking in 2002 about deflation after the housing bubble, as Greenspan was still priming it. But that's the point. The public is cut out until everything is decided.

Nothing will change until the investigation creates both answerability and a full tilt public debate.

Friday, January 09, 2009

Employment Unraveling, Bushes Not Yet Burning

The US unemployment rate hit 7.2% in November, which the excellent labor journalist Louis Uchitelle notes is "the highest unemployment rate since January 1993, when the country was still shaking off a jobless recovery from the 1990-91 recession. The loss in total jobs for 2008 was the largest since 1945."

This brings Bush II's unemployment legacy exactly back to the percentage level of his father Bush I's. See the photos of the presidential gathering in which Barak Obama is flanked by the Bushes, both looking as doltish and mediocre as they are. The Bushes were arguably the worst political dynasty in US history, and should never be heard from again, except if dragged to the dock in chains for any of a range of lethal stupidities.

Most sectors are struggling, and people trying to work on their own are getting hammered. The LAT has a good piece on trucking. This used to be an industry where someone without a college degree could a) make a more or less middle class living and b) be their own boss. This workplace combination of financial stability and self-direction was supposedly the cornerstone of political democracy. It's vanishing for college folks, and even more quickly for most non-college people as well.

Nest Egg news is staying dismal. Since the residence is the main form of working class and middle class wealth, the fall is crushing the main source of psychological and actual economic advancement for the majority in our long and continuing period of stagnant majority incomes. This has been especially hard on the Black middle class. Doug Henwood of the New Left Observer (#118) points out that houses are still overpriced when expresses in relation to incomes.
Through the 1980s and 1990s, the average existing house cost 3.25 times the average household's income; it got to 4.7 times at the end of 2005. Prices would have to decline another 4% to get to their long-term average. we're getting close,though after a boom like we had, some overshoot seems likely.
Here's one of Henwood's charts, which paints a nice picture of the temporary 2000s m-c wealth effect.


Krugman is stuck in "size matters" mode for the stimulus. He's getting a bad feeling that Obama is turning Republican deficit hawk at exactly the wrong moment. It's hard to blame him.

The depth of investor sorrows is shocking. Money Morning is, like it sounds, run by pro-capitalist investment advisers. One of their main writers started the year by noting that Finance is a "bearish sector," and then saying, "The entire industry appears to be scaling down to a fraction of its 2007 size, as many of the innovations of the last 20 years turn out to have been spurious."

Well Wow! How do we bury their toxic waste without blowing ourselves up with it?

Thursday, January 08, 2009

Facing Up to Trickle Up

I was reminded of another Principle for making anything better economically by this good discussion between Dean Baker and Arun Gupta about the Obama - really the Summers - Stimulus. They were pointing out that it's too small, and too skewed towards tax cuts instead of direct spending, and too skewed towards business and not enough towards poor people. There's continuous enormous need among leaders to give money to the top, e.g. the biggest banks. It doesn't matter how incompetent they are, as long as they're at the top. But money to middling and poor people? Much less likely. And it doesn't matter how much more likely they are to spend it.

Gupta estimated that "Business tax cuts give about twenty-five to thirty cents on the dollar." And he went on to point on that a lot of tax-cut-driven consumption goes to buying foreign-made products. Yesterday Obama promised $1000 per household. Gupta noted like many others that the best way to stimulate the economy is infrastructure spending.

Can the US, after decades of tireless slamming of the entire government sector - from unemployment offices to urban bus systems - spend real money on public services? That's where the real rebuilding will be. But it will mean spending big money on public services that are woven into the lives of the non-wealthy. Think the hybrid city bus, new job training centers with Google-quality equipment and solar capacity built into the materials. US leaders have lived for 40 years by nickle-and-diming the public sector, taxing the middle (with social security taxes on top of income), and moving money up to the top.

Does Washington know how not to give and give to the rich?

I don't think so, and hence half the current stimulus is going to be for business, who will hoard a lot of it, give the rest to shareholders and senior executives, and use another piece to increase their market dominance by buying weaker rivals.

4. Face up to our 19th century social Darwinism. And purge it.

Monday, January 05, 2009

Principles for Dummies

Some basic stuff:

1. Stimuli should develop society, not just support consumption. Obama's Big Whopper is likely to have much infrastructural stuff that's good, and good reimbursements to states for the unemployment, health and education costs that support and develop the workforce, not to mention the population as a whole. It's also getting bloated with tax cuts for business to try to buy Republican support. And you - you get five hundred dollars! Krugman reminds us of how beleaguered development policies are in US politics:
The biggest problem facing the Obama plan, however, is likely to be the demand of many politicians for proof that the benefits of the proposed public spending justify its costs — a burden of proof never imposed on proposals for tax cuts.

This is a problem with which Keynes was familiar: giving money away, he pointed out, tends to be met with fewer objections than plans for public investment “which, because they are not wholly wasteful, tend to be judged on strict ‘business’ principles.” What gets lost in such discussions is the key argument for economic stimulus — namely, that under current conditions, a surge in public spending would employ Americans who would otherwise be unemployed and money that would otherwise be sitting idle, and put both to work producing something useful.
2. Economics depends on social systems and not just markets.

For example. China is wondering whether export-driven growth is a form of sustainable development. Measured in yuan, and corrected for inflation, China's export revenue fell over 11% in the month of November.

Barak Obama called on China to shift its economy from foreign to domestic demand. But the piece explains why this is unlikely:
Shifting toward a greater reliance on domestic demand is not easy. Chinese households have one of the world’s highest savings rates because the country’s social safety net is in tatters, with families receiving scant government help with education costs, medical care and retirement; the average hospital stay costs the equivalent of two years’ wages for the average Chinese worker.
On the same poing, NYT writer Joe Nocera offers a comprehensive piece on risk models and tells the story of the "Value at Risk" model. It failed to be predictive for at least 4 reasons: it generally used only two years of data - artificially peaceful up-years as it turned out. It also fails to account for the rare or exceptional events that change everything - the "black swans" that appear after thousands of white ones make you assume all swans are white. It can be gamed by traders who load up on low-risk positions with huge downsides in the "less than 1%" tail of the curve, and finally, it hides huge losses in that statistically ignorable tail.

The moral of the story is that markets are far less regular and predictable than is often assumed - that is, many many regularities can be overturned by one big irregularity, as when the Dow of 2008 undid the gains of the six previous years in a few weeks.

Nocera also makes clear how intellectually conflicted the trading community is right now: views of VaR aren't just diverse; they are deeply unresolved. For example:
One risk-model critic, Richard Bookstaber, a hedge-fund risk manager and author of “A Demon of Our Own Design,” ranted about VaR for a half-hour over dinner one night. Then he finally said, “If you put a gun to my head and asked me what my firm’s risk was, I would use VaR.” VaR may have been a flawed number, but it was the best number anyone had come up with.
The risk models need lots of interpretation, which mixes market math with people and institutions, which also destroys the ideal of the self-regulating market and brings society and the state back in.

That's where we are now. Unresolved. With little progress in 2008 toward real financial redesign. Which leads to

3. Investment decisions have to be made by society, not by investors and bankers alone.

Does this mean I want NASCAR Bob to have a vote on what Goldman Sachs does with its / our money? YES. But not in the sense that Bob overrides or wrecks decisions made with professional expertise. I mean in the sense of
  • accountability. How about basic accounting? We don't yet have this with bailout money, and even finance professionals are alarmed.
  • explicit public goals. Finance doesn't do anything for 80-90% people. Yet another summary of the stats: "As of 2004, the wealthiest 10 percent owned about 78 percent of all equity in businesses, 75 percent of all equity in individually-held stocks, and 65 percent of mutual funds." Only the top of the middle-class has much money tied up in any investment outside of the house they actually live in:


Why were the trillions spent on credit default swaps not on bridges and post-silicon photovoltaic research?

We have to talk.

Thursday, January 01, 2009

Happy New Year!

Something funny about money for a change.

While you're still laughing, read this wrap-up of Wall Street 2008 - good riddance!